Why bother with all the insurance? (It’s a scam anyway right?!?)
Up until Dec ‘08 I thought insurance was an evil entity designed to suck the funds out of your wallet for that odd chance of something catastrophic happening. My ex bf’s parent’s home burned down. We’re talking about a barely got out alive, barefoot in -30F Chicago weather kind of burned down. The house was destroyed and they were homeless.
And then came Farmers Insurance (cue cheesy music.) We were adequately insured and Farmer’s helped us get a place for them to live, paid out for the complete reconstruction of the homFe. They will move in a little later this year. They now have a beautiful home that wouldn’t have been possible had they chosen some shady insurance company with little to no coverage. That being said, finding the right insurance coverage is kind of like playing musical chairs in the dark with no music… and no chairs… It is a frustrating experience….
How to get the right insurance coverage at the right price…
Credit Scores
Insurance companies WILL check your credit scores when they insure you. If you’re missing your payments and don’t care what’s happening on your credit file, chances are that you wouldn’t care about your driving record or making sure your home is maintained, etc. A bad credit score can end up costing you at least $200 extra in premiums for them to cover you!
Which Company to go with?
There are a lot of choices out there for insurance. You can go with the mom and pop insurance company with a shady payout ratio and history of claim denial or you could go with the larger companies that have better financial standings and ratings. I check out insurance company ratings at AM Best before deciding calling up the agent. A quick google finance search of the company will also give you an idea of their financial situation if they are publicly traded.
I found a company, now what?
Look online or in the phone directory and call up your nearest agent. The next step is to open up your trusty old excel workbook and start listing your policy details. This is a mock-up of my actual policy workbook.

Insurance workbook for easier comparison
Insurance companies have various names for the same coverage. It’s important to sit down with the agent and go line by line over each item. Don’t be embarrassed to ask questions. You’re paying for the coverage, why not understand what youre paying for?
How much insurance is enough?
Make sure you are adequately covered. If your home is worth $1 mill, dont insure it for the bare minimum required. You’ll pay the price if something happens.
On your autos, if you are driving around a junky old car, dont buy comprehensive coverage. If you have assets, buy more than the state required minimum coverage. Chances are, if you’re in an accident and it’s your fault, the injured party’s medical bills alone will eat through your policy pretty quick.
Consider an umbrella policy if you have substantial assets as this coverage kicks in when your first policy depleted.
Make sure you clarify whether you are getting an actual cash value or a replacement cost on your policy. Lets say someone breaks into your home and steals your stereo system that cost you $1,000 in 1984. Under actual cash value, the insurance company will say that the stereo was only worth $30 and will give you that amount. Under replacement cost, they will ascertain a fair price for a comparable stereo in today’s dollars and pay out accordingly.
Check if you qualify for other discounts.
Often, insurance companies will give you a break on premiums if you insure your home and auto with them. Is your kid getting good grades? Mention that for a better rate. Take a defensive driving course. These courses cost very little and can save you a decent amount on your coverage. Are you a Gamma Alpha Zeta Mu Mu alum? Ask if they have a discount for that. Mention that you have a home alarm system and a fire extinguisher in your home. All those count too!
Check and Recheck your coverage and policies
The biggest mistake people make is not checking whether their coverage is up to date. With falling home prices, you need to adjust your coverage to fit the lower values. Don’t feel compelled to stick with the same agent or company. Shop around using your trusty excel workbook and make sure you’re getting the best deal for the coverage. I have taken my business to 3 different companies in the last 4 years. My average savings are between $2,000 to $3,000 over the life of my policies. Taking the time out to do the homework will help you understand what you’re paying for and how to make the most of your coverage at the right price.